GREAT INVESTIGATIONS

The Dreyfus Bordereau: When Junk Science Dressed as Math Convicted an Innocent Man

In 1894, French anthropometrist Alphonse Bertillon used a fake mathematical analysis of handwriting to help convict Captain Alfred Dreyfus of treason. The argument was unfalsifiable: matching handwriting proved guilt, mismatching handwriting also proved guilt.

What this story trains

A theory that explains every possible outcome predicts none. Bertillon's reasoning is a textbook unfalsifiable structure, decades before Popper formalised the term.

Logical ReasoningPattern Recognition

Read the full story inside BrainGym

The full version is a Daily Nutrition session: progressive text reveal that pauses at sentence boundaries for embedded multiple-choice questions tied to the reasoning. You cannot skip ahead; the next paragraph unlocks when you engage with the current one.